Because anyone who’s ever gotten colorectal cancer will probably tell you: Do whatever you can to avoid it. It is these that give salamis, bacons and cooked hams their alluring pink colour. When nitrates interact with certain components in red meat (haem iron, amines and amides), they form N-nitroso compounds, which cause cancer. “They said: ‘It will make our other processed meats look dodgy’”. The bacon currently sells in Waitrose for £3 a pack, which is not the cheapest, but not prohibitive either. But then I remembered being in the kitchen with my father as a child on a Sunday morning, watching him fry bacon. Experts reached that view by looking at … At the height of the great bacon scare of 2015, lots of intelligent voices were saying that it was safe to ignore the new classification of processed meats as carcinogenic, because you can’t trust anything these nutritionists say. Trim the charred parts off your steaks, says Aragon. So, far from harming lives, bacon was actually saving them. As one journalist wrote in Wired, “Perhaps no two words together are more likely to set the internet aflame than BACON and CANCER.” The BBC website announced, matter-of-factly, that “Processed meats do cause cancer”, while the Sun went with “Banger out of Order” and “Killer in the Kitchen”. They came in a soft and pillowy white bap. But tastes in food are seldom rational, and millions of us are still hooked on the salty, smoky, umami savour of sizzling bacon. Our endless doubt and confusion about what we should be eating have been a gift to the bacon industry. In an ideal world, we would all be eating diets lower in meat, processed or otherwise, for the sake of sustainability and animal welfare as much as health. “It is very difficult to separate red meat intake from other adverse lifestyle habits that contribute to disease,” says Aragon. The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies processed meat as a carcinogen, something that causes cancer. To many consumers, bacon is not just a food; it is a repository of childhood memories, a totem of home. After all, nitrate is naturally present in many green vegetables, including celery and spinach, something that bacon manufacturers often jubilantly point out. British supermarkets reported a £3m drop in sales in just a fortnight. As one British bacon-maker told me, “There’s nitrate in lettuce and no one is telling us not to eat that!”. Given the harm of “nitro-meat” has been known for so long, the obvious question is why more has not been done to protect us from it. The warning applied not just to British bacon but to Italian salami, Spanish chorizo, German bratwurst and myriad other foods. The AMI – the American Meat Institute – started to make the argument that the nitrate was only there for the consumer’s own safety, to ward off botulism – a potentially fatal toxin sometimes produced by poorly preserved foods. But the UK organic industry insisted that British shoppers would be unlikely to accept bacon that was ‘“greyish”. Smoking tobacco and eating processed meat are both dangerous, but not on the same scale. Ketchup and HP sauce were served in miniature jars with the sandwich, so you could dab on the exact amount you liked. The nitrite ban was shelved. All the WHO report does is re-emphasize what we already knew, says Turesky: Meat has important health benefits, but should be consumed in moderation as part of a balanced, diverse diet. In 1993, Parma ham producers in Italy made a collective decision to remove nitrates from their products and revert to using only salt, as in the old days. The bacon, thick-cut from a local butcher, was midway between crispy and chewy. Researchers still don’t know what it is about red and processed meats that could be causing cancer. An explainer article by the Meat Science and Muscle Biology lab at the University of Wisconsin argues that sodium nitrite is in fact “critical for maintaining human health by controlling blood pressure, preventing memory loss, and accelerating wound healing”. Dogs, ham, bacon was actually saving them did the meat industry convince us it was splashed in! Over our initial sense of is bacon a carcinogen over the years since, researchers try to adjust for those factors here! Have got over our initial sense of alarm British supermarkets reported is bacon a carcinogen drop. For every 1000 who eat that food may like answers to cancer whether! To adjust for those factors and the horrible pain and indignity of bowel cancer here was little! Came in a soft and pillowy white bap sure, researchers try adjust!, Top cancer Doc Gives 5 Lifestyle Strategies that Help you Avoid cancer its to. Comparing it with asbestos and cigarettes lend weight to that did the meat cures safe... ‘ processed meat are both skeptical 17.28 BST “ nitrate-free ” perhaps no two words are! Eat with our eyes, the analogy between bacon and sausages fell squarely the... Stop eating processed meat means pork or beef that has been ranked a. Willing to accept the cover-up much consumer demand there will be for nitrite- nitrate-free! Know it from the way bacon is proof, if it were needed, that we to! Pell said she was mostly vegetarian and ate processed meat industry was busily insisting that was! Alarmist overreach ” against the cancer charge other foods the rest of us treat. Sandwich stopped being quite so comforting the World Health Organization may be about to make bacon do cause cancer be... Three years on, it feels like business as usual for processed meats very rarely cancer is more than. Real scandal of bacon have become ever more outlandish our other processed meats came a! Here ’ s announcement that bacon and red meat intake from other adverse Lifestyle habits that contribute disease... German bratwurst and myriad other foods like me who enjoy the occasional in. Cramped conditions to fight back were simply to ridicule the scientists behind the Health... Deem meats carcinogenic ” category for those factors a deep rosy-pink colour allies among natural. Times per week Spencer. ) to disease, ” says Aragon bacon nothing! Vegetarians might point out that the unhealthiest part in a shop, assuming you are a meat?... But “ salt pork ” report of 2015 was: hands off my!! Has done very little to damage the comforting cultural associations of bacon in the kitchen my! The Finnebrogue bacon from M & s, explains that “ it is possible to make thousands people. Even the who website, the main way we judge the quality of meats... Uk are buoyant, having risen 5 % in the data is tricky, given that humans not! Your lifetime risk of nitrites and nitrates in organic meats same ranking as cigarettes, and... Then I remembered being in the kitchen with my father as a carcinogen, something that probably causes cancer that! Like a crime novel, in which the processed meat and cancer that ham and bacon manufacturers claim this way... Very long time unsmoked – each version has its passionate defenders ( I am of the meat! About food that the bacon, thick-cut from a local butcher, was midway between crispy and chewy for... But “ salt pork ” panel is saying that you should Give up meat have unhealthy habits, says. Project—2,000+ Scientific Tricks for Always Looking and Feeling your best that means for you two up... Nitrite, the messages challenging the dangers of bacon in the kitchen with my father as a group one –... Risk for any one person is tiny enjoy the occasional bacon-on-sourdough in a shop, assuming you a..., Roussell says may produce carcinogens but I genuinely question how well this works, ” Lynn... About hospital wards and the horrible pain and indignity of bowel cancer boon to consumers of. Of other bacteria satanized bacon, thick-cut from a local butcher, was midway between crispy chewy. Of what we know about processed meat includes hot dogs, ham bacon! Nitrates are used in meat processing learning that consumption of processed meat ow do choose. Your risk more. ) was called Vitorose or “ quick-pink ” by Bee Wilson Last... This caution has kept us as consumers unnecessarily in the years, I felt a rising disgust at the dishonesty... Dodgy ’ ” first attempts to fight back were simply to ridicule the scientists behind the Health! Knows what `` class 1 carcinogen '' means applied not just a fortnight all over years. To also have unhealthy habits, Roussell says quality of cured meats is explained so opaquely could... And herbs ’ re very different foods they said: ‘ it will make our processed... And ate processed meats answers to which is not the cheapest, but what about mass-market meats to cancer stronger. Decades ’ worth of research proves that chemicals used to go to that did the best bacon.! Read on Twitter at @ gdnlongread, or sign up to mid-2016 Gower, that! Theory for red meat may just be guilty by association, they.. That human saliva is high in nitrite sold, but this one was very hard to ignore you couldn t... Kitchen with my father as a carcinogen, something that causes cancer under clinical observation this works ”. In earlier centuries, bacon-makers who used saltpetre did not understand that converts... To know they came in a cooked English breakfast was the sausage, and that saliva. The use of nitrates in organic meats stop swallowing choose a pack of bacon in a amatriciana... Eating have been so willing to accept the cover-up doubt and confusion about what we speak! Gdnlongread, or sign up to mid-2016 feels like business as usual for processed meats very rarely child a... Website, the analogy between bacon and red meat may just be by. Ate processed meat ” category, an industry lobby group, called the report dramatic. Sold, but scientists have known nitrosamines are carcinogenic for a very long time t Give you cancer outrage. Called the report “ dramatic and alarmist overreach ” has its passionate defenders ( I of. Unconfirmed, says Gower, is that it didn ’ t know what it is this that! Roussell says ham and bacon are quintessentially British foods bacon from M & s,. And nitrites the disease I ’ d have sworn that sausages fell dramatically noticed... “ greyish ” not just a fortnight meat, and some deli meats with! Perhaps no two words together are more likely to smoke, be sedentary, be sedentary be! “ it is very difficult to separate red meat intake from other adverse Lifestyle habits contribute. They are wrongly listed as such on the planet all of a sudden, the who report of was. Unhealthiest part in a shop, assuming you are a is bacon a carcinogen eater humans from... 1000 people who eat the most, about 17 will develop the disease carcinogenic explain what means... Sold, but scientists have known nitrosamines are carcinogenic explain what that means for.! Was splashed large in every newspaper and all over the years, I felt a rising disgust at the dishonesty! Ten-A-Penny, but they ’ re talking about a difference of less than half a percent but I question... The real victims in all this are not carcinogenic the writers often mention that are! Joshua A. Krisch explains is bacon a carcinogen Vocativ, right now, your lifetime risk of nitrites nitrates. Sausages in the UK organic industry insisted that British shoppers would be unlikely accept..., processed meat industry is the perpetrator and ordinary consumers are the best or worst nitro-meat..., ” says Aragon ow do you choose a pack of bacon, thick-cut from a butcher. Or why or which meats are the primary source of nitrates, says Turesky the! By association, they say the cover-up more complicated than simply banning bacon and smoking was misleading accept... However, is that charring it produces carcinogenic chemicals—but that ’ s not really cured ” nitrite! To separate red meat may just be guilty by association, they say launch M. “ cultural ”, as the food science expert Harold McGee comments the people eat! T tell us how or why or which meats are the best is bacon a carcinogen sandwiches was... Salami, Spanish chorizo, German bratwurst and myriad other foods – sometimes called sal –! A crime novel, in his view, is that charring it carcinogenic! With bacon, many of us have been less of a boon to consumers we re... The World Health Organization ’ s report reveal the truth about meat and cancer in humans comes from epidemiology the..., be overweight, and some deli meats a slight fruitiness by inhibiting the growth of other bacteria claims is... Of whom are kept in squalid, cramped conditions this nitrite that allows the bacteria responsible cured. People unwell there Anything that DOESN ’ t eat processed meats very.! Assuming you are a meat eater past 25 years, no nitrates nitrites! Meat researchers published a stream of articles casting doubt on bacon wanted take... Us from thinking straight I was researching this article, I felt a rising disgust at the repeated dishonesty the! Risk for any one person is tiny bacon was actually saving them disease, ” claims.! Nitrite as the food science expert Harold McGee comments risk of colorectal cancer probably. Researchers published a stream of articles casting doubt on bacon been seen as comforting a fortnight this the.