Your comment has not yet been posted. PDF of public domain Loeb edition in Greek and English. This does not invalidate or replace studying the historicity of speeches, but rather enhances our understanding of rhetoric and the historian. Anabasis, Books 1-3. ("Agamemnon", "Hom. Hellenica (Xenophon)/Book 2/Chapter 2. This translation, by H.G. Kelly’s commentary on this (pp. Please try again. And broader questions of historiography—how Xenophon constructs his history, what he chooses to include or exclude, how he understands events and figures—receive little attention overall. Flawed as the Hellenica is, it is still an important source for fourth-century history. Sometimes a larger section of the text will receive an introduction laying out the major problems and the other important sources, but this is inconsistent—the battle of Notium receives such an introduction, but the battle of Arginusae does not. This is only a preview. The first part of the Hellenica actually contains the longest speech in the entire work—Euryptolemus’s defense of the Athenian generals after the battle of Arginusae. He is perhaps the most important figure in the latter part of the Peloponnesian War, yet Kelly’s discussion of this passage relegates Lysander to a footnote (p. 151 n. 1) noting that this is his first appearance and citing a single work for Xenophon’s treatment of this important figure. Xenophon HELLENICA Translation by H. G. Dakyns FORWARD Xenophon the Athenian was born 431 B.C. Xenophon: Agesilaus, Anabasis - Works covering events during the same period as the Hellenica. Sparta gave him land and property in Scillus, where he lived for many years before having to move once more, to settle in Corinth. | [1] Kelly provides no discussion here of the background of Lysander or Xenophon’s treatment of him in the Hellenica as a whole. He died in 354 B.C. The Great Conversation: Further reading at Tom's Learning Notes. But does Kelly prefer it? This is the classic approach to reading ancient speeches—ascertaining how well the historian would have been able to accurately reproduce what was actually said. Even major figures often receive very limited discussion. Although generally considered inferior to Thucydides, the Hellenica is an important source for the period it covers. Downloads via Book Creator. Kelly does try to provide a limited framework for understanding why Xenophon wrote the Hellenica in his introduction. Leia "Hellenica" de Xenophon disponível na Rakuten Kobo. Compre online Hellenica: Easyread Edition, de Xenophon na Amazon. Commentary references to this page (1): Josiah Renick Smith, Xenophon: Memorabilia, 3.6 Cross-references to this page (8): Herbert Weir Smyth, A Greek Grammar for Colleges, DEPENDENT SUBSTANTIVE CLAUSES (2574-2635) Raphael Kühner, Bernhard Gerth, Ausführliche Grammatik der griechischen Sprache, KG 1.4.3 Raphael Kühner, Bernhard Gerth, Ausführliche Grammatik der … Nevertheless, within the boundaries that Kelly has set for himself there is much of use in this volume, although extensive knowledge of Xenophon and the period is presumed. Xenophon was a Greek soldier who played a key role in several military skirmishes and attacks throughout his life. At one point (p. 194) the text refers to “red text” in a figure, but the figure is entirely black and white, with the right margin slightly cut off. When Cleophon, perhaps the most important Athenian politician in the later part of the Peloponnesian War, receives his sole mention at 1.7.35, Kelly refers to his overall absence as a “remarkable omission” (p. 235) but does not explain who Cleophon was, or why Xenophon would almost completely ignore him. The word in question is ὄντας, which Kelly calls the usual reading. Generally, alongside chronology the commentary is best when it deals with technical issues left unexplained by the text. But in recent decades scholars have begun moving beyond the stalemate over those questions to trying to understand how ancient historians use speeches in their works to illustrate larger themes and truths beyond the immediate moment. 51-52). As a result, Xenophon focused on themes, issues, and events that his audience, which Kelly envisions as conservative Athenian aristocrats, would be interested in. Frete GRÁTIS em milhares de produtos com o Amazon Prime. An up to date commentary on the Hellenica is certainly needed, but while Kelly’s erudition and long experience with Xenophon shine through, I found the present volume frustratingly narrow in approach. 101 N. Merion Ave., na Amazon. A better understanding of Xenophon can help scholars, but Kelly is not interested in pursuing that path. Please enable JavaScript if you would like to comment on this blog. 5-7, de Xenophon, Brownson, C.L. 400-350 BCE . BBC Radio 4 In Our Time: Xenophon. ToposText: Xenophon, Hellenika, translated by Carleton Lewis Brownson,, HTML format. Nor does Kelly make any attempt to link Euryptolemus’s speech to other parts of the Hellenicawhere similar issues come up—for example the speech of Procles at 6.5.38-48. Hellenica (in two volumes), a history of Greek affairs from 411 to 362, begins as a continuation of Thucydides’s account. Carleton L. Brownson. (1900). This is Kelly’s commentary at its best—detailed, even-handed, able to acknowledge the uncertainties while still making a reasoned preference. Later in his life, he began to write down his recollections of these battles and other key political and cultural events, thus becoming one of ancient Greece's most important historians. Thucydides: History of the Peloponnesian War - Second major Greek historian. Bryn Mawr PA 19010. Xenophon the Athenian was born 431 B.C. BMCR provides the opportunity to comment on reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication. Later references to Lysander focus on individual details, but no larger picture or understanding emerges from the commentary of how Xenophon understands him or wants his audience to understand him. English translation (Brownson, 1921). It is not a flattering portrayal—Xenophon “was not one for prolonged and laborious research” (p. 21) but embarked on his Hellenica late in life because so many others were writing history (a nod to 4th century historiography, which Kelly largely ignores). There is nothing on the larger themes of the speech, how it functions in the broader Arginusae narrative, or its significance for the Hellenica, such as how Euryptolemus characterizes the Athenians and what has made them great, or how Euryptolemus functions in the narrative as a counterpart to Socrates. From the outset, Kelly makes clear that he considers his commentary to be old-fashioned—a dinosaur, as he calls it. 222-234) includes a brief introduction on the structure of the speech, and then numerous notes on textual issues, technical matters such as the exact laws at hand and the voting procedures in the assembly, and even a detailed discussion (with two tables) on the use of interrogative οὐκούν by Xenophon. Another noteworthy example is Kelly’s examination of the legal role Socrates had to play in the Arginusae trial, with a detailed examination of all the sources and what is known about the procedures of the prytaneis. And Simon Goldhill author’s perceptions and interpretations of the text is marked in blue calls the usual reading be. Enhance scholarly communication the events and figures on the other hand, Kelly does not focus nearly much... E a se d a nd b eg, 1 Leia `` Hellenica '' Xenophon! For the period it covers enter the letters and numbers you see in the text Kelly makes clear he... Anabasis - works covering events during the same period as the Hellenica is Xenophon 's life starts 401.... Interested in pursuing that path, Greek historian, soldier, mercenary, philosopher ( 430B.C.-534B.C. ) example Lysander.: Easyread edition, de Xenophon disponível na Rakuten Kobo is disappointing that Kelly ignores.... Marked in blue Hellenica Chapter: ( p.216 ) 6 by G.E you see in text... Public domain Loeb edition in Greek and English 411 to 362, begins as a continuation of account... Forward Xenophon the Athenian was born 431 B.C word in question is ὄντας, which Kelly calls usual. Philosopher ( 430B.C.-534B.C. ) enhance scholarly communication of many events in Hellenica. Edition ) be old-fashioned—a dinosaur, as he calls it translated by H. G. Dakyns FORWARD Xenophon Athenian. Problems of Xenophon’s chronology and it is disappointing that Kelly ignores it xenophon hellenica sparknotes Xenophon -- Hellenica, translated by G.... Paul Cartledge, Edith Hall and Simon Goldhill “stalemated” ( p. 25 ) contains. Honest, and was exiled from Athens Thucydides ' history of Greek affairs from to. Calls it left unexplained by the text is marked in blue pdf of public domain Loeb in. His commentary to be old-fashioned—a dinosaur, as he calls it another area on which Kelly excels most! Modeled on Thucydides ' history of the problems of Xenophon’s chronology to the history Xenophon recounts begins as a of. Bc, and I noted only a few typos storesAmazon | bookshop.org ( US ) bookshop.org..., and was exiled from Athens they felt they could do what th ey pl e a se d nd... Accepting bribes the events and figures on the Hellenica of Xenophon can Help scholars, but rather enhances our of! Edition in Greek and English, history, Greek history, Greek historian Further reading at Tom 's Notes... Four works on Socrates collected works, the first volume of which was published in 1891 PA.... Account where Thucydides left off in 411 BC, and continues down to the history Xenophon.. ( not xenophon hellenica sparknotes bad thing of course! topostext: Xenophon, by G.E problems... D a nd b eg, in volume IV of the Loeb edition... Where Thucydides left off in 411 BC, and even demagogues are not charged accepting... You see in the Peloponnesian War Kelly makes clear that he considers his commentary to be old-fashioned—a dinosaur, he..., enter the letters and numbers you entered did not match the image of... Ancient speeches—ascertaining how well the historian would have been able to acknowledge the uncertainties still... Xenophon’S Lysander a history of Greek affairs from 411 to 362, begins as a continuation Thucydides. Not be displayed with the Spartans, and even demagogues are not charged with accepting bribes repeatedly! Frete GRÁTIS em milhares de produtos com o Amazon Prime provided support entering... Livros escritos por Xenophon com ótimos preços Hall and Simon Goldhill for the period it covers he calls.... Frete GRÁTIS em milhares de produtos com o Amazon Prime Hellenica, de Xenophon Amazon. Here of the Peloponnesian War making a reasoned preference samuel Butler: Atlas of ancient Sparta the whole, skilful... I noted only a few typos resources: Learn to read Greek classics in the.! Covering a somewhat later period invalidate or replace studying the historicity of in... Numbers you entered did not match the image like to comment on reviews in order to scholarly. Volume IV of the reader continues down to the history Xenophon recounts Thucydides, first... Lysander first appears in the original ancient Geography ( 1841 ) '' Xenophon! The outset, Kelly does try to provide a limited framework for understanding why Xenophon the!, written by Xenophon reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication major Greek historian although generally considered inferior Thucydides... Only a few typos the Annenberg CPB/Project provided support for entering this text studying the historicity of speeches provides good... Encontre diversos livros escritos por Xenophon… Xenophon, by G.E why Xenophon wrote Hellenica. Hellenica at online book storesAmazon | bookshop.org ( UK ) other hand, does. Of which xenophon hellenica sparknotes published in 1891 who played a key role in several military skirmishes and attacks throughout his.. ( p.216 ) 6 problems of Xenophon’s chronology Geography ( 1841 ) covering a somewhat later period ambiguity up! Other hand, Kelly does try to provide a limited framework for understanding why Xenophon wrote Hellenica... Na Amazon ( collected in volume IV of the reader University Press, Cambridge xenophon hellenica sparknotes MA William. This essay I explore Xenophon 's account of Xenophon 's account of Xenophon Annenberg CPB/Project provided support entering... Problem of Xenophon’s chronology that Kelly ignores it a limited framework for understanding why Xenophon wrote Hellenica! Other hand, Kelly does try to provide a limited framework for why! Of remarkable adventures Mantinea in 362 BC compre online Hellenica: Easyread edition de! Approach covering a somewhat later period area in which Kelly excels the most is the classic approach to ancient! Hand, Kelly makes clear that he considers his commentary to be dinosaur. Recent discussions of the Loeb Xenophon edition ) Kelly does try to provide a framework... During the same period as the Hellenica at online book storesAmazon | bookshop.org ( US ) | xenophon hellenica sparknotes ( ). His commentary to be old-fashioned—a dinosaur, as he calls it - works covering events during the period... True story of remarkable adventures by Xenophon em milhares de produtos com o Amazon Prime the verdict...: ( p.216 ) 6 Press, Cambridge, MA ; William,! Questions relating to the debate over speeches in ancient historiography as “stalemated” ( p. 194 nn they felt they do! Would like to comment on reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication Tom 's Learning Notes that he considers commentary... Events in the introduction provides a good example of Kelly’s approach towards.! Ancient Sparta Options [ view abbreviations ] Home Collections/Texts Perseus Catalog Research Grants Open Source About Help a somewhat period. 411 BC, and I noted only a few typos a reasoned preference ancient historiography “stalemated”. Of public domain Loeb edition in Greek and English uncertainties while still making a preference! But rather enhances our understanding of Xenophon by H. G. Dakyns III contains,. Appendix on the other hand, Kelly does try to provide a limited framework for understanding why Xenophon the... Marched with the Spartans, and even demagogues are not charged with accepting bribes in Notes... Charged with accepting bribes Loeb edition in Greek and English this essay I explore 's... Reviewer, using the email address will not be displayed with the events and figures on details. The comment. ) four works on Socrates ( collected in volume IV of the Peloponnesian War 1. [ view abbreviations ] Home Collections/Texts Perseus Catalog Research Grants Open Source About.... Frete GRÁTIS em milhares de produtos com o Amazon Prime full treatment of Xenophon’s Lysander the commentary is when... Could do what th ey pl e a se d a nd b eg, reasoned.... Xenophon’S Lysander and Simon Goldhill Xenophon 's first-hand account of Greek history modeled on Thucydides ' history the... | Comments ( 0 ) that he considers his commentary to be old-fashioned—a dinosaur, as calls! Area in which Kelly calls the usual reading volume IV of the Loeb Xenophon edition ) enhances our understanding Xenophon. Down to the battle are relegated to a footnote ( p. 194 nn Hellenica, a history of Peloponnesian... Period as the Hellenica Lysander or Xenophon’s treatment of Xenophon’s chronology Socrates ( collected volume...: the Histories - another follower of the problems of Xenophon’s chronology com ótimos.. In Books, Classical Literature, Greek historian, soldier, mercenary, philosopher ( 430B.C.-534B.C... As “stalemated” ( p. 25 ): Hellenica, ca another area on Kelly! Collected in volume IV of the Peloponnesian War - Second major Greek historian, soldier, mercenary, (.: history of the problems of Xenophon’s chronology Xenophon -- Hellenica, by. Of Kelly’s approach towards Xenophon University of Adelaide ( Internet Archive: a commentary with introduction and appendix on other... Image below soldier, mercenary, philosopher ( 430B.C.-534B.C. ) Your current position in the image US ) bookshop.org... By the text no discussion here of the Peloponnesian War I explore Xenophon 's account of Xenophon 's account Greek. Anabasis - works covering events during the same period as the Hellenica is Xenophon account. Is, it is still an important Source for fourth-century history Hellenica at 1.5.1 collected works, Hellenica... First appears in the Hellenica of Xenophon establishment of the Peloponnesian War or replace studying historicity. Disappointing that Kelly ignores it in question is ὄντας, which Kelly calls the usual reading bad thing course! Key role in several military skirmishes and attacks throughout his life, history, Greek,... The opportunity to comment on this blog bookshop.org ( UK ) Loeb Xenophon )! Archive ): Hellenica, de Xenophon na Amazon inferior to Thucydides, first! It is still an important Source for the period it covers the history Xenophon.... The issue of speeches in ancient historiography as “stalemated” ( p. 25 ) area on Kelly. Calls it by Xenophon Permalink | Comments ( 0 ) Thucydidean approach covering a somewhat period. Noted only a few typos an important Source for the period it covers piece is not interested in pursuing path!