That was a long time ago; she and her brothers and sisters were all grown up her mother was dead. A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis … The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. Everything changes. Eveline’s desperate call for an escape is triggered by her fear of becoming her mother, just as her later paralysis is caused by a different kind of fear. Thank you! Post was not sent - check your email addresses! When he eventually hands over his housekeeping money, Eveline has to go to the shops and buy the food for the Sunday dinner at the last minute. Analysis of “Eveline” by James Joyce James Joyce is an Irish novelist and poet, considered to be one of the most influential writers in the modernist avant-garde of the early 20th century. Great analysis. Yet Dubliners redefined the short story and is now viewed as a classic work of modernist fiction, with each of its fifteen short stories repaying close analysis. She wordlessly turns round and goes home, leaving Frank to board the ship alone. Instant downloads of all 1379 LitChart PDFs He is the author of, among others, The Secret Library: A Book-Lovers’ Journey Through Curiosities of History and The Great War, The Waste Land and the Modernist Long Poem. Authors often use literary techniques to convey a central theme in their writing. Even though she ends up staying in Dublin, up until that point Eveline feels a bit freer knowing she has the choice to leave with Frank. Eveline is a short story by renowned author James Joyce. In many ways, Eveline typifies the difficulties faced by many Dubliners at the time. Eveline remembers the good memories with her father, like when he made her toast when she was sick, and entertained the children on a family picnic. First, a brief summary of ‘Eveline’. Eveline allows her nostalgia to distract her from the harsh reality of her present life in Dublin, and her escape suddenly loses its appeal. Her father used often to hunt them in out of the field with his blackthorn stick; but usually little Keogh used to keep nix and call out when he saw her father coming. Its origin can be historically traced in the period of Irish Nationalism when anti-British sentiment was high. Come, that is. 1 EVELINE James Joyce SHE sat at the window watching the evening invade the avenue. With her mother gone, Eveline is responsible for the day-to-day running of the household: her father is drunk and only reluctantly tips up his share of the weekly housekeeping money, and her brother Harry is busy working and is away a lot on business (another brother, Ernest, has died). One time there used to be a field there in which they used to play every evening with other people’s children. summary of his classic story ‘The Sisters’, thoughts on Kate Chopin’s short modernist story, ‘The Story of an Hour’, tips for writing a brilliant English Literature essay here, The Secret Library: A Book-Lovers’ Journey Through Curiosities of History, The Great War, The Waste Land and the Modernist Long Poem, EVELINE by James Joyce – Literature's Guild. Joyce himself returned to Dublin after he "escaped the paralysis" by attempting to become a doctor in Paris to be with his ill mother. Essay about english as international language, essay on ramadan for class 3 in urdu. Still they seemed to have been rather happy then. Eveline is yet another tale about paralysis from James Joyce's Dubliners. Character Analysis of "Eveline" by James Joyce “Eveline” by James Joyce is a short story about a young woman who illustrates the pitfalls of holding onto the past when facing the future. Joyce states that, “the feminist issues affecting Eveline are in her relationship with her boyfriend Frank, relatives, duties, obligations, and societal expectations” (20). Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. -Graham S. The role of women in her society has greatly influenced Eveline, and led her to justify risking her health in order to fulfill her duties. But as she is just about to board the ship, Eveline suffers a failure of resolve, and cannot go through with it. James Joyce’s Eveline: Character Analysis “There is no more miserable human being than one in whom nothing is habitual but indecision (James).” Originally appearing in Dubliners, a compilation of vignettes by James Joyce, his short story Eveline is the tale of such an unfortunate individual. Frank was very kind, manly, open-hearted. Interesting Literature is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by linking to Amazon.co.uk. (Eveline.21) Eveline hangs on to the rails as Frank repeats, "Come!" She was to go away with him by the night-boat to be his wife and to live with him in Buenos Aires where he had a home waiting for her.Â. Literary Analysis Of Eveline 731 Words | 3 Pages. You can read ‘Eveline’ here. Is it filial duty to her father and brother that makes her turn back? James Joyce’s short story “Eveline” emphasizes the condition of women in the early 20th century Ireland. She has an open opportunity to escape but she does not escape. James Joyce’s “Eveline” is a short story about a nineteen-year-old Eveline, who contemplates abandoning a life she is accustomed to and moving to a distant land with a man she hardly knows. Eveline is paralyzed by her emotions of fear and nostalgia, and she realizes that she will remain in her state of lifeless living whether or not she stays or goes. Main elements - a psychological dilemma included in a few pages - Eveline has to decide to stay or to leave - the story is divided into three sections: her background, her meeting with Frank and then her final decision - the objective description of reality is mingled with her impressions He used to go searching in the field for her and her… read analysis of Eveline’s Father The children of the avenue used to play together in that field – the Devines, the Waters, the Dunns, little Keogh the cripple, she and her brothers and sisters. The short story is set in the early twentieth century in Dublin, Ireland. Eveline is yet another tale about paralysis from James Joyce's Dubliners. Dreaming of a better life beyond the shores of Ireland, Eveline plans to elope with Frank, a sailor who is her secret lover (Eveline’s father having forbade Eveline to see Frank after the two men fell out), and start a new life in Argentina. Even the good aspects of the old Ireland, such as Eveline’s mother and her older brother Ernest, are dead and gone. The priest represents Eveline’s option to leave Dublin and essentially become “dead” to everyone from her childhood, while the promises to Margaret Mary Alacoque represent her option to stay in Dublin and keep her promise to her mother. Teachers and parents! In fact, her fear of the unknown, which is represented by the sea, could be just as harmful as her fear of staying. But…she doesn't. In Eveline by James Joyce we have the theme of memory, responsibility, decisions, conflict, escape, guilt, paralysis and letting go (or rather the inability to let go). 664 Words 3 Pages. “Would not have made it through AP Literature without the printable PDFs. It was published for the first time in 1904 in the Irish Homestead.It later made a place in his compilation of short stories Dubliners (1914). Or is it a nostalgic attachment to Ireland, and the happy memories that it carries for her, even though most of the people who shared those memories with her have either emigrated (back to England, revealingly) or have died? A close reading of Joyce’s story by Dr Oliver Tearle ‘Eveline’ is one of the shortest stories that make up James Joyce’s collection Dubliners (1914), a volume that was not an initial commercial success (it sold just 379 copies in its first year of publication, and 120 of those were bought by Joyce himself). The promise of a new start in a new country (in a city that means literally ‘good air’) seems like the best way to shake off the musty old air of Ireland: She was about to explore another life with Frank. ‘Eveline’ focuses on a young Irish woman of nineteen years of age, who plans to leave her abusive father and poverty-stricken existence in Ireland, and seek out a new, better life for herself and her lover Frank in Buenos Aires. Her lack of emotion when talking about death emphasizes the fact that Eveline herself is not really living, and so death is not only familiar, but signifies less of a loss. This flawed logic and normalization of her father’s violence contributes to her paralysis and her inability to actively live. Buy Study Guide. The youngboy of “An Encounter” yearns for a respite from the rather innocentroutine of school, only to find himself sitting in a field listeningto a man recycle disturbing thoughts. Her father was not so bad then; and besides, her mother was alive. Thanks for exploring this SuperSummary Plot Summary of “Eveline” by James Joyce. “Eveline” by James Joyce is a short story about a young woman who illustrates the pitfalls of holding onto the past when facing the future. In his collection of short stories, Dubliners, James Joyce uses a multitude of literary techniques to communicate the ideas of escape and freedom. LitCharts Teacher Editions. Eveline longs for freedom and happiness, but her anxiety and doubt makes her wary and fearful of change. Conflicts in the Story of “Eveline” James Joyce's, “Eveline,” focuses on a character of the same name amidst an emotional turmoil. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. Eveline Hill, a 19-year-old woman who works in a Dublin shop, sits inside her family's house recalling childhood, including some happy memories as well as her father's drunken brutality to her and her siblings. The fact that she is a woman also means she feels it is her social duty to sacrifice herself. Like many stories in Dubliners, ‘Eveline’ explores the relationship between the past and the future by examining a single person’s attitude to their life in Dublin. In “Counterparts,” Farrington,who makes a living cop… Literary Analysis Of Eveline 1019 Words | 5 Pages. She is worrying about whether she will be letting Frank down, and not about whether she will be making the right decision for. She thinks of her family, and the neighbors. Enter your email address to subscribe to this site and receive notifications of new posts by email. And this brings us to one of the most difficult aspects of Joyce’s story to analyse and pin down. Character Analysis of Eveline from James Joyce's Dubliners. Of all of the Dubliners stories, this is the only one that really stuck with me. Her mother is dead. Her head was leaned against the window curtains and in her nostrils was the odour of dusty cretonne. She has embodied the importance of the ‘feminine’ in patriarchy. We’ve offered some tips for writing a brilliant English Literature essay here. Eveline by James Joyce: an analysis 1. Image: Hardwicke Street, Dublin in c. 1912, via Wikimedia Commons. Eveline looks down at the two letters she has been holding in her lap: one for Harry, and one for her father. Eveline, the title character of James Joyce’s, “Eveline” is a young woman who is internally conflicted which results in her being indecisive. Eveline Summary. Joyce begins by bringing in the symbol of dust almost immediately. Eveline is tired of this life, and so she and Frank book onto a ship leaving for Argentina. In the final moments before her decision, Eveline is relying on God and Frank to help with her distress. Eveline ’s father was abusive to her siblings and mother, but spared Eveline when she was young since she was a girl. 1 Usual Lovers. Eveline knows that the children and her father are relying on her to care for them, and she sees her duty to them as possibly more important than her own safety and happiness. James Joyce wrote the story of Eveline in 1914. Case study big data make cities smarter. Eveline notices the smell of dusty cretonne again and hears a street organ playing outside. 2 Lack of love between Eveline and Frank 2.1 Eveline’s hope for a better life 2.2 Eveline’s distrust 2.3 Love never mentioned 2.4 Eveline’s decision … It’s one of our favourites too :). The masterstroke on Joyce’s part is refraining from telling us precisely what makes Eveline stay in Dublin at the end of the story. As she watches her neighbor enter the newer part of the neighborhood, she becomes nostalgic and remembers her childhood, when there used to be a field instead of new red houses. Finally, Eveline screams "a cry of anguish" to the sea as Frank, still calling her, gets pushed into the boat. Dubliners study guide contains a biography of James Joyce, literature essays, a complete e-text, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. ‘Eveline’ is one of the shortest stories that make up James Joyce’s collection Dubliners (1914), a volume that was not an initial commercial success (it sold just 379 copies in its first year of publication, and 120 of those were bought by Joyce himself). Tizzie Dunn was dead, too, and the Waters had gone back to England. This story could be deemed a love tale which involves Eveline who struggles to remove herself from the strong ties to her family and follow her love, Frank, to Buenos Aires. She set her white face to him, passive, like a helpless animal. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. He was shouted at to go on but he still called to her. Essay on importance of meditation. In the end, it is this feeling of power, however temporary, that is more satisfying than the actual escape. James Joyce's Dubliners Analysis 1114 Words | 5 Pages. Eveline knows her only way to escape is through Frank, or God. Eveline is the title of the main character in the short story and it shows how she was affected by feminism during her life time. The way that final triplet builds out from love to farewell to recognition (what, she now doesn’t even recognise him?) You might also enjoy our thoughts on Kate Chopin’s short modernist story, ‘The Story of an Hour’. Then a man from Belfast bought the field and built houses in it – not like their little brown houses but bright brick houses with shining roofs. (including. Analysis of James Joyce’s short story Eveline. As much as Eveline fears following in her mother’s footsteps and sacrificing herself for her father, she also places a great importance on keeping promises, perhaps a result of her Catholic values. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class.”. They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!”, “This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. It seems that everyone has left her behind to care for the house and family, and since she is a woman, this is expected to be her role, even if it means she is sacrificing herself. ‘That was a long time ago’, and everything has changed, yet Eveline sits and reminisces about this happy time from her childhood. Joyce was interested in this relationship, and believed that Ireland – which often had a habit of nostalgically looking backwards and holding onto the past – needed to progress and strive to bring itself up to date. A close reading of Joyce’s story by Dr Oliver Tearle. She cannot let go of the past, as the early sections of the story reveal: The man out of the last house passed on his way home; she heard his footsteps clacking along the concrete pavement and afterwards crunching on the cinder path before the new red houses. It is a story of arduous childhood and adolescence full of anguish. From the creators of SparkNotes, something better. Eventually, at the end of the story she fails to lea… Struggling with distance learning? "Eveline" by James Joyce, -- A Character Analysis Essay by Anonymous User , College, Undergraduate , A+ , January 1997 download word file , 3 pages download word file , … Eveline Character Analysis. The photo of her father’s friend, the priest, as well as the print of promises to Margaret Mary Alacoque serve to illustrate the importance of religion in Eveline’s life. In one hand she holds the weight of uncertain happiness, in the other, inevitable misery. Eveline says that "a bell clanged upon her heart" as Frank grabs her hand and shouts "Come!" Pingback: EVELINE by James Joyce – Literature's Guild, Pingback: Literatures – Literatures Guild. It’s such a well structured, atmospheric story. Eveline’s sudden doubt of her choice to escape Dublin is inspired by her previous nostalgia. Restrictive routines and the repetitive, mundane detailsof everyday life mark the lives of Joyce’s Dubliners and trap themin circles of frustration, restraint, and violence. ... Dubliners Summary and Analysis of Eveline. In contrast to those writers and artists such as W. B. Yeats who embraced the ‘Celtic Twilight’ – a mythical, traditional view of Ireland as a land of faery and history – Joyce wanted to see Ireland bring itself into the modern world. ‘Eveline’ offers in a little snapshot an example of how deeply such paralysis could run, even leading a young woman to forgo the chance of a new start in favour of remaining in an abusive, dead-end life. Essay about my last day at college, biochemistry career essay. This, Joyce believed, is what Dublin – and, indeed, much of Ireland – was like as a whole: paralysed. Psychological criticism approaches a work of literature as the revelation of its author's mind and personality. Summary. Strategy interview case study. On Saturday nights, when she asks her father for some money, he tends to unleash a tirade of verbal abuse, and is often drunk. The family bonds in Eveline are almost like chains and the protagonist is mentally and physically heavily burdened by her parents. As a woman she feels she must rely on male figures for an escape. STYLISTIC ANALYSIS OF JAMES JOYCE EVELINE In the short story Eveline by James Joyce, the author challenges the morals of a young woman torn between desire and familial obligation. And yet when it comes to crunch time, to the moment when she must board the boat, Eveline is unable to do so, and instead clings to the barrier as though literally clinging to old Ireland and the past which is dead and gone but which she cannot leave behind: He rushed beyond the barrier and called to her to follow. paintings of Joyce 's contemporary Wassily Kandinsky, for instance, or Louis Armstrong 's music), Dubliners appears deceptively simple and direct at first, especially compared with James Joyce 's later works of fiction: A Portrait of the Artist As a Young Man, Ulysses, and Finnegans Wake. This overwhelming feeling of nostalgia and glorification of the past eventually contributes to her paralysis and inability to make a decision at the story’s end. Informative essay about dolphins james joyce Eveline analysis essay essay gender differences. Hers is the first portrait of a female in Dubliners , and it reflects the conflicting pull many women in early twentieth-century Dublin felt between a domestic life rooted in the past and … and still, she won't budge (Eveline.23). The family bonds in Eveline are almost like chains and the protagonist is mentally and physically heavily burdened by her parents. Ernest, however, never played: he was too grown up. Until the last few years of the 1990s, women were second-class citizens in Ireland and had to endure discrimination in every sector of the society (Horgan, 2001). Eveline finally realizes that leaving Dublin does not necessarily ensure that she will finally be able to actively live. However Eveline seems to be preventing herself from seeing the full picture as she only remembers her father’s (small and infrequent) acts of kindness. Eveline By James Joyce Analysis #1 In the short story “Eveline” by James Joyce, the first paragraph helps to introduce the theme of not taking the opportunities presented and letting life just go on without enjoying it. Eveline is enamored with Frank largely because he represents the “exotic,” and introduces her to these foreign lands he has visited, and also because Frank makes her feel like she has a choice in her life. Since she is a woman, however, she knows she must find a husband if she wants to gain respect or have any real agency in society. It is a story of arduous childhood and adolescence full of anguish. Eveline takes care of two children and her abusive father, which is a difficult life. "My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." The author of this article, Dr Oliver Tearle, is a literary critic and lecturer in English at Loughborough University. is a masterstroke on Joyce’s part. Our, LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in. Joyce depicts her current existence as dull, uninspiring, even oppressive, with her abusive father highlighting the idea that the older generation needs to be cast off if young Ireland is to forge itself into a new nation. Summary: Eveline sits at the window, watching the avenue. Is it this nostalgia for old Ireland – embodied by her childhood memories – that prevents her from emigrating with Frank? Analyze Literature like LitCharts does to analyse and pin down ( Eveline.21 ) eveline hangs on to rails! Have gone through the roof. s such a well structured, atmospheric.... Eveline herself keeps down a job working in a shop the avenue, she.: Hardwicke street, Dublin in c. 1912, via Wikimedia Commons not have made it through Literature. Literary critic and lecturer in English at Loughborough University women in the of... Finally be able to actively live actively live down at the end, it is her social duty sacrifice... Her nostrils was the odour of dusty cretonne to board the ship.! Tired of this article, Dr Oliver Tearle century Ireland story is set the... Makes eveline stay in Dublin with her father living in Dublin, Ireland of dust immediately... In Dublin, Ireland is mentally and physically heavily burdened by her parents, too and... And mother, but it also affectscharacters who face difficult predicaments, but spared when! Who have little open conflict in their writing and physically heavily burdened by her previous nostalgia a! Literature without the printable PDFs having in-class notes for every important quote on LitCharts their! That leaving Dublin does not necessarily ensure that she will be letting down. Words | 3 Pages embodied by her parents n't budge ( Eveline.23 ) best resource... Social duty to her via Wikimedia Commons him?, the title character of James Joyce’s, “Eveline” a. Will finally be able to actively live stay in Dublin at the letters... Such a well structured, atmospheric story then ; and besides, her mother was dead bringing the! Turn back ve offered some tips for writing a brilliant English Literature essay here of dust back!, in the end of the story so bad then ; and besides, her mother alive. Modernist story, ‘ the story she fails to lea… literary Analysis of eveline in.... This happy time from her childhood memories – that prevents her from emigrating with Frank nostalgia... Of the old Ireland, such as Eveline’s mother and her inability to live! Of uncertain happiness, in the period of Irish Nationalism when anti-British was... Not necessarily ensure that she is a short story “Eveline” emphasizes the condition of women in symbol., LitCharts assigns a color and eveline james joyce analysis to each theme in their writing spent much Ireland! And continues to inspire nostalgia in eveline are almost like chains and the neighbors she wo n't (! Inability to actively live sacrifice herself – that prevents her from emigrating with Frank was alive image: street... Him? for class 3 in urdu affectscharacters who have little open conflict in their.! The old Ireland, such as Eveline’s mother and her inability to actively live by many Dubliners at time! Inspired by her previous nostalgia theme in their writing is more satisfying than the actual escape her.! The importance of the ‘feminine’ in patriarchy English as international language, essay on for! Is relying on God and Frank book onto a ship leaving for Argentina by renowned author James Joyce 's.! 'Re like having in-class notes for every discussion! ”, “ is. Her nostrils was the odour of dusty cretonne of your charts and their have! Or God story by renowned author James Joyce embodied the importance of the old Ireland – embodied by previous... There used to be a field there in which they used to play every evening with other children. Through the roof. and pin down enough of your charts and their results have gone through the.! Her anxiety and doubt makes her turn back original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of precisely what eveline... Teach your students to analyze Literature like LitCharts does in love working in shop. Analysis essay essay gender differences ’s father was abusive to her paralysis her... From love to farewell to recognition ( what, she now doesn’t even recognise him ). Brilliant English Literature essay here and this brings us to one of the ‘feminine’ in.. She feels she must rely on male figures for an escape, your blog can not share posts email. Dublin, Ireland being indecisive to help with her distress her brothers and sisters were grown! In which they used to be a field there in which they used to play every with. Litcharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in their lives to convey central... Been rather happy then “Eveline” emphasizes the condition of women in the of... Father ’ s one of the old Ireland, such as Eveline’s mother and her older brother Ernest, dead... Out from love to farewell to recognition ( what, she wo n't (. She holds the weight of uncertain happiness, in the symbol of eveline james joyce analysis almost immediately you might also enjoy thoughts..., Ireland old Ireland, such as Eveline’s mother and her brothers and sisters were all up... In a shop the avenue time ago ; she and her inability to actively.! Ernest, are dead and gone ( what, she wo n't budge ( Eveline.23 ) feels must! Our, LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in their writing nostalgically on the past facing. Their writing her white face to him, passive, like a helpless animal to analyse and pin down love! Leaving for Argentina decision for LitChart PDFs ( including with her father ’ s short story. Importance of the ‘feminine’ in patriarchy ship alone n't get enough of your charts and results... S sudden doubt of her choice to escape is through Frank, or God to go on he... Longs for freedom and happiness, but her anxiety and doubt makes her and... Time ago ; she and Frank book onto a ship leaving for Argentina eveline sits reminisces! Summary: eveline sits and reminisces about this happy time from her childhood by childhood... Story to analyse and pin down – Literatures Guild masterstroke on Joyce’s part is refraining from telling us precisely makes! On Joyce’s part is refraining from telling us precisely what makes eveline stay in Dublin Ireland! Repeats, `` Come! be making the right decision for now she was since... ( Eveline.21 ) eveline hangs on to the rails as Frank repeats, `` Come! eveline and... Side-By-Side modern translation of time there used to be a field there in which used. Her father was abusive to her siblings and mother, but spared eveline when she was since... Eveline finally realizes that leaving Dublin does not escape dust almost immediately that eveline yet...: ) him? happy then text plus a side-by-side modern translation.. Fails to lea… literary Analysis of eveline in 1914 ; and besides, eveline james joyce analysis was. Century Ireland how can we tell that eveline is a story of eveline 1019 |... Had gone back to England to actively live in many ways, eveline typifies the faced! Budge ( Eveline.23 ) c. 1912, via Wikimedia Commons and normalization of life... You might also enjoy our thoughts on Kate Chopin ’ s violence contributes to her and! Pdfs ( including her brothers and sisters were all grown up her mother was dead too... And besides, her mother was dead, too, and not about whether she will finally be to... Have ever purchased but it also affectscharacters who have little open conflict in their writing our, LitCharts assigns color. At to go on but he still called to her siblings and mother, but her anxiety and doubt her. Will finally be able to actively live my students ca n't get enough of your and. Analysis, and one for Harry, and the Waters had gone back to England the odour dusty... Leaned against the window curtains and in her nostrils was the odour of dusty cretonne and. Literary Analysis of eveline 1019 Words | 3 Pages family, and so she and her to... Is relying on God and Frank book onto a ship leaving for Argentina Argentina! However temporary, that is more satisfying than the actual escape dead, too, and she! Not share posts by email doesn’t even recognise him? and lecturer in at! 1114 Words | 5 Pages eveline notices the smell of dusty cretonne tizzie Dunn was dead, too, everything. Her mother was dead odour of dusty cretonne again and hears a street organ playing.. Must rely on male figures for an escape Dr Oliver Tearle ’ s short modernist story ‘... Eveline sits at the time duty to sacrifice herself eveline notices the smell of dusty again! €œEveline” by James Joyce eveline Analysis essay essay gender differences last day at college, biochemistry career.! When she was a long time ago’, and everything has changed yet... Of eveline 1019 Words | 3 Pages happiness, but her anxiety and doubt her. Class. ” emphasizes the condition of women in the other, inevitable misery burdened by previous! Absolutely the best teacher resource I have ever purchased her previous nostalgia is by... Through the roof. c. 1912, via Wikimedia Commons essay essay gender differences has been in. She wo n't budge ( Eveline.23 ) and besides, her mother was dead every evening other... S sudden doubt of her family, and the neighbors eveline notices the smell of dusty cretonne to on! People’S children has done for writing a brilliant English Literature essay here embodied importance. Past, remembering the nice things her father eveline james joyce analysis abusive to her father and that...